
A family restaurant that nourishes the body and feeds the soul
By Sue Baldani
Growing up, Frank Castronovo enjoyed helping his father Francesco in the family restaurant. Today, he and his four brothers have followed in their father’s footsteps. “An immigrant from Sicily, my dad had a passion for authentic Italian food,” he says. “He felt that opening a pizzeria was a great way to bring his culture and his food to the United States.”
Master Pizza, which opened its first location in Livingston in 1990, is doing just that while staying true to its motto, “Fast, Fresh & Delicious.” One day, when Frank wanted to make his sauce even better, he brought in his Sicilian mother, Dorotea.
Frank’s wife, Marylee, explains, “My father-in-law is deceased, but my mother-in-law is still alive. She’ll be 87 this July, and she’s an amazing cook. When Frank struggled with his sauce, he picked her up and brought her to the restaurant. While she was in the kitchen with him, adding a pinch of this and a pinch of that, he wrote it all down. Afterwards, it was perfect.”
Some of Master Pizza’s most popular offerings include Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Nonna Pizza, Chicken Parmigiana, and Sunday Meatballs. “We focus on quality ingredients,” says Frank. “Everything is made fresh, from our dough to all of our sauces. We take pride in using decades-old family recipes.”
For the past two years, the restaurant has been voted Best Pizza in Essex County. “It is a huge honor,” he says. “We are incredibly grateful to our loyal customers for their support. It tells me that people recognize the love and effort we put into what we do. At the end of the day, it’s so rewarding to me to know we have made people happy.”
Over the past 35 years, Frank and his staff have heard everything from “This is the best pizza I have ever had” to “Local gem” and “My go-to spot for pizza”. “We have seen kids grow up and now come back with their own kids to have a slice of Master Pizza.” The restaurant is primarily take-out and delivery, but also provides catering for all types of events.
Marylee, who handles the accounting and other duties, also coordinates donations and sponsorships. “The most rewarding thing for me in this business is to see how many people and organizations we’ve helped,” she says. “I truly feel like we’ve been so blessed in this business and with the community.”
Over the years, Master Pizza has supported school events, given back to St. Barnabas Hospital, provided gift cards and pizza kits for various fundraisers, and sponsored many local sports teams. This ongoing support comes not only from its Livingston restaurant, but also from its West Orange, Union, and Carlstadt locations.
Frank and Marylee are grateful for their team, and even their children help out with social media, contest ideas, and marketing. “We are proud to be a family-run business that has grown with the community,” says Frank. “We have always tried to evolve while staying true to our roots.”
When he first purchased the business in 1990, its tagline was “At Master Pizza, every pie is a work of art”. “It really is how we approach the business. We try to give the customer everything they ask for and more.”
379 East Northfield Road
Livingston, NJ, 07039
973-992-4500
MasterPizzaOnline.com
Written for Inside Livingston magazine in New Jersey.

